top of page

CONTENT

Content is the strength of the argumentation presented. covers the quality of the rebuttal and ability to defeat opposing arguments. A speaker with a high content mark will present arguments that are highly relevant, with clear explanations and flag the impacts of their arguments. They will be consistent and thorough in their explanation of why their set of beliefs are the strongest arguments in the debate.

STYLE

Style is the ability to deliver your arguments persuasively. There is no one particular style that will be appropriate for all speakers and all debates just as there is no one set of arguments that will win all debates. It does however encompass a number of general elements that improve the impact of a speech. These including how a speaker uses their voice, their use of gestures, their use of rhetorical techniques and their engagement with the audience.

STRATEGY

Strategy encompasses three things. The first is their structure and timing, the second is their understanding of the issues of the debate, and the third is flow and links. Structure and timing refers to a speaker who fills their time and does not under or over speak.

Understanding the issues of the debate follows on from this clear sense of understanding what the key issues in any given debate are. There should be a clear link between points made by a speaker and also from one speaker to the next e.g. adding a team tagline.

 

JUDGING CRITERIA:

Each substantive speaker (speaker’s 1-3 for each team) can theoretically be awarded a maximum of 100 points. 40 points for content, 40 for style and 20 for strategy. The reply speech is worth a maximum of 50 points, 20 for content, 20 for style and 10 for strategy. However the actual World Schools speaker scale runs from 60 – 80.

This means the minimum a speaker can receive for:
1) Content is 24 (12 for Reply Speeches)
2) Style is 24 (12 for Reply Speeches)
3) Structure is 12 (6 for Reply Speeches)

This means the maximum a speaker can receive for:
1) Content is 32 (16 for Reply Speeches)
2) Style is 32 (16 for Reply Speeches)
3) Structure is 16 (8 for Reply Speeches)

NOTE TO ADJUDICATORS: 

-All debates will follow the World Schools Format and will be scored in the same manner. 

-All individual scores must range from a minimum of 60 points to a maximum of 80 points – no exceptions.

-There must be a 1 minute discussion interval between each speech where  the three speakers of both teams can communicate within their teams to discuss points or prepare for their next speaker.

-The judge may start repeatedly knocking if there is an over-time of more than 10 seconds and may not take into consideration what the speaker has said after this time.

-Judges MUST complete the digital scoresheet (using the rubric if required) and send it to dubaidebateleague@gmail.com after every round.

    1. Judges must encourage debaters to ask POIs

    2. The debating teams must offer feedback to the opposing                   team once the debate has concluded (before the winning team is announced).
    3. Judges should give general feedback to the team.
    4. Scores and detailed personal feedback can be shared but this is                up to the discretion of the judge.

bottom of page